Peanut Butter & Jelly Thumbprint Cookies

Peanut Butter & Jelly Thumbprint Cookies

My friend Alyssa and I were just watching this movie where they made these crazy huge sandwiches called Fool’s Gold. Picture this: an entire loaf of italian bread, an entire jar of peanut butter, an entire jar of jelly, and bacon. Lot’s of bacon. Alyssa and I instantly had a serious craving for peanut butter sandwiches, but for some reason, we wanted them with bananas instead of bacon and jelly. Trying to keep it classy and a tad bit healthier.

As we were chomping away on our yummy sandwiches and watching our movie filled with fool’s gold sandwiches, it hit me. I should combine peanut butter, jelly, and banana to make the ultimate cookie. Introducing the peanut butter and jelly thumbprint cookies.

I’ve loved thumbprint cookies ever since my classmate’s grandma gave me one with a hershey’s kiss in first grade. The gooeyness of the middle with the chew of the soft cookie outside holding it all together in a little cocoon. In this case, the jelly melted perfectly in with the peanut butter. And by using banana to replace egg, it created this delicious banana underlying flavor that isn’t too strong, but just a little hint of it. By the way, these cookies are gluten-free, dairy-free, egg-free, and vegan!

Obvs they are best enjoyed warm out of the oven, but they are pretty good the next day as well. As people walk through my house (AKA the dog groomer) they grab one and I hear a “this is delicious!” come out of their cookie filled mouths. That’s a success right there.

Peanut Butter & Jelly Thumbprint Cookies

I finally finished finals this week after a grueling semester of studying and working hard on my projects. I am so excited for finishing this semester up because it’s the most wonderful time of the year where I get to spend my days around the fireplace, curled up with a chai tea latte, eating one of these cookies (hint hint) and being with my family. There’s nothing like the holiday quality time enjoyed during this season.

I always find myself so thankful for my family and friends during the holidays, but shouldn’t we be thankful and enjoy each other’s company all the time?

Isn’t that what it’s all about?

This year has been filled with a lot of personal growth for me, and as I look back on it now that it’s coming to an end, I’ve realized how important the people I love are to me. I guess as you grow up you really realize the importance of family, in all it’s many different forms. Gosh, how old and wise do I sound now?

Peanut Butter & Jelly Thumbprint Cookies

Anyway, ALOHA, this really wonderful, health conscious company inspired me in their “bringing a dish to pass” initiative. Since I was feeling all nostalgic and such, as stated above, I knew I wanted to be apart of it and I decided these cookies were the perfect recipe. Over the last few days, I’ve had countless moments around the kitchen table with friends, family, and yes, the dog groomer, sharing these cookies and talking about life.

I’ve decided to start my new year’s resolution list a little early, and the first thing to be added is: enjoy the small moments with the people I love.

Sharing a cookie might seem simple, but it has a big impact. I encourage you to make these cookies and see the happiness you’ll bring to the people who mean the most to you.

So grab that glass of dairy-free milk, a nice warm blanket, your sweet doggy, and your family and huddle around the fireplace sharing stories and eating plates of peanut butter & jelly thumbprint cookies. Also make sure to check out some other really great holiday recipe ideas from ALOHA’s fun recipe page!

Happy holidays!

Peanut Butter & Jelly Thumbprint Cookies

Peanut Butter & Jelly Thumbprint Cookies
Author: 
Serves: about 20 cookies
 
Ingredients
  • 1 cup peanut butter
  • 1 cup packed light brown sugar
  • 1 mashed banana
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 1 pinch of salt
  • 1 cup gluten-free baking flour
  • grape jelly for the filling (about ¼ cup, depending on how much you want in each cookie)
Instructions
  1. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.
  2. In a large bowl, mix together the brown sugar and mashed banana. Add in the peanut butter, baking powder, vanilla and salt and mix until well combined. Mix in the baking flour until smooth.
  3. Roll a spoonful of cookie dough in your hands to form a ball, then place on a greased (or parchment paper lined) baking sheet. Continue until all the cookies are made.
  4. Place your thumb in the center of each cookie and press down to create a small indentation in the middle. The cookie might crack a little, which is fine. If it cracks too much then just press it back together.
  5. Fill each indentation with a small spoonful of jelly, continuing until all the cookies are jelly filled.
  6. Place in the oven to bake for 10 minutes.
  7. When done baking, remove and let cool.
  8. Serve on a platter or give them away as gifts in tin cookie containers.

 This post is not sponsored by ALOHA, but they do have really cool products. All opinions are my own. 

Peppermint S’mores Chocolate Bark

Campfire Peppermint S'mores Chocolate Bark from Vivian & Me

In all of my holiday themed posts so far this year, how could I have possibly managed to overlook one of my favorite quintessential holiday-themed food items: peppermint! I love peppermint because it usually involves sweets, specifically chocolate. And after making this bark, it might officially be my new favorite holiday snack. The peppermint is totally optional (if you leave it out, you're crazy) but I love the zing of it throughout each … Read more

Campfire Skillet Brownies For Two

Campfire Skillet Brownies -- the best dessert for a cozy night by the fire with your love!

Hey Mom and Dad, I'm talking to you. You deserve a little break every once in a while. Especially during this time of year, when life is filled with family and happy chaos. Tonight is one of those times after putting the kids to bed, where you both can sit by the fireplace, curled up on the sofa, with the Christmas tree lit up, romantic holiday music playing, and enjoy a big slice of these easy campfire (yes, I can put some marshmallows on top … Read more

Balsamic Cranberry Pork Tenderloin + Vivian Takes London!

Cranberry Pork Tenderloin and Creamy [Dairy-Free] Mashed Potatoes

I bet you're looking in your refrigerator at all those leftover cranberries that you didn't use last week, wondering what you could do with them, really not wanting to throw them away. Oh boy do I have a surprise for you ;) This balsamic cranberry pork tenderloin is another winner from Hunter Davis over at the Dish and the Spoon. Make sure to schedule your spring break meals with him now because he will fill up! Popular guy right … Read more

The Best Ever Skillet Cornbread Dressing

Cornbread-Dressing-1

Thanksgiving is tomorrow! Thanksgiving is tomorrow! Do the happy dance. Oh yeah. I'm sooo excited! The official wintery holiday times are kicking off TOMORROW, TOMORROW, I LOVE YA TOMORROW (someone please name that movie in the comments...) and then I can finally start singing Christmas carols, drink hot apple cider, sit by the fire place in my pajamas, and string lights all throughout my room for my next favorite month of the whole year. But … Read more

Creamy Mashed Potatoes

Creamy Vegan Mashed Potatoes from Vivian & Me

I know you love it when I use words like creamy on an allergy food blog because it usually means I'm posting something really good that is hard to find in our world of eating. And with that lovely intro, I present to you these tasty vegan creamy easy-to-make mashed potatoes. Woot woot. If you're looking for that last minute side dish that won't take up much space on your stovetop and also won't deter from your focus on that coconut milk … Read more

Quick and Easy Cranberry Orange Crisp

Cranberry Orange Crisp from Vivian & Me

The holidays are a comin'! We are in the final stretch! We have almost made it to the blissfully sweet few weeks known as the happy holidays. Yesss. By now most of the cooking wizards of the world (United States?) have their Thanksgiving meal all planned out and ready to go. Maybe they've already been to the grocery and everything. But, if you're anything like me and you're just now planning your Thanksgiving meal at the very last minute (hi, … Read more

Traditional Vegan Green Bean Casserole

Vegan Green Bean Casserole

Am I really writing a post on a Saturday? This is epic. Once-in-a-lifetime. You are so lucky. I hope you know that this is serious if I'm breaking into my weekend relaxation time (ha! actually catch up on homework time) and oh boy are you in for a treat. Drumroll please... I am (jumping up and down) thrilled to bring you Vivian & Me's guest chef for our Thanksgiving week recipes! This is Hunter Davis, my Hunter twin, and he is a … Read more

Pomegranate Fruit Salad with Honey Lime Dressing

Pom-Salad-2

I'm currently writing through big giant scoops of this scrumptious fruit salad. Poms are the bomb. I was skeptical because first of all I've never eaten pomegranate on my own (like not ordering it at a restaurant) and I was nervous about the de-seeding of the pomegranate and second of all I was nervous about the mix of flavors that I was combining. But I quickly learned that apples, pears, pomegranate seeds, walnuts, and a delicious … Read more

Lunchbox Monday: The Festive BLT Box

Lunchbox Monday: The Festive BLT Box

I have survived many experiences this week. Remember that conference I was talking about in my last post? Well it was a success! Vivian did an amazing job talking about her dairy allergy and the blog. She was so nervous! We also showed our popsicle video we made for Vita Coco this summer and everyone loved it! We got to talk with all different kinds of educators from all over the world about blogging and dairy allergies and education. We … Read more